Tips for Taps Blog
Of the dozens of household water filters making waves on the market today, few are as popular or as well marketed as the Big Berkey Water filter. Despite the online coverage, however, these sleek, two-chamber systems have never been independently certified to NSF/ANSI standards. So how do you know if your Berkey water filter is really effective?
You performance test it. Read on to learn everything you need to know about performance testing your Berkey, including what contaminants to look for and hot tips for optimal testing.
Table of Contents:
- Performance Testing Your Berkey
- Why Should I Performance Test My Berkey?
- What Contaminants Should I Performance Test My Berkey for?
- How to Performance Test Your Berkey
- Why Trust Tap Score?
Performance Testing Your Berkey
Full performance tests are the best way to find out how effective your Berkey really is at removing contaminants.
With proper performance testing, your water is tested before and after it passes through your filter:
- The first test analyzes the quality of your water before filtration—this sample would be taken straight from your tap.
- The second test analyzes the water after it has passed through your Berkey water filter, allowing you to compare your results with the state of your unfiltered water.
Are Red Dye Tests Performance Tests?
No, even if you’ve seen videos or read blog posts detailing a Berkey water filter’s performance in red dye tests, or in lowering TDS levels, these are not performance tests and should not be considered a thorough evaluation of Berkey filters.
Why Should I Performance Test My Berkey?
Performance testing helps you understand your particular water needs and how your Berkey fits in with those needs.
Everyone’s water is unique to their environment and their home water system. By presenting you with a baseline assessment of water quality, you’ll be able to understand any potential changes in your Berkey’s performance down the line.
Performance testing is also the best way to verify the type of bold claims common throughout the water treatment industry.
For example, Berkeys claim to remove certain contaminants at an amount greater than “99.9999%.” But can they, really? And for how long? Performance testing your Berkey is a simple way to guarantee your filter is living up to its claims.
Making Up for Missing Certifications
Most importantly, performance testing helps make up for missing certifications.
Despite the popularity of Berkey water filters and the variety of coverage floating around online, Berkeys—specifically their Black Berkey Elements—are not certified to any NSF/ANSI standards. These standards include a rigorous performance testing regiment performed in a laboratory environment.
What Contaminants Should I Performance Test My Berkey for?
We always recommend getting a baseline picture of your water quality so you can determine what your specific contaminant concerns are. Remember, full performance tests require two identical tests, one for your water source, one for your filtered water.
Should I Test My Berkey for Bacteria and Other Pathogens?
You should absolutely test for bacteria if your water comes from a well, a local spring, or harvested rainwater. (Public utilities specifically work to kill microbes by chlorinating water before distributing it.)
Bacteria and Filter Maintenance
Berkey claims removal rates of 99.9999% for bacteria and >99.999% for viruses. But filters that remove bacteria or other pathogens do not necessarily kill them, allowing them to remain and possibly proliferate on the filter elements.
If you know for certain your water is microbially contaminated, it’s important to change your filter soon afterward.
For those with large, harvested water supplies, (e.g. rainwater or spring water), it is best to chlorinate your water supply before filtering it. This way, you can avoid promoting microbial growth on your filter, and use it to remove residual chlorine and its impacts on taste and odor.
Should I Test My Berkey for Lead and Other Heavy Metals?
Yes, heavy metals are the number one contaminant to test for, regardless of source. Berkey claims to remove over 99.9% of lead and many other heavy metals (such as copper, mercury, iron and manganese), while leaving in hardness minerals (calcium and magnesium).
A test should include information on both.
Should I Test My Berkey for Nitrates?
Nitrates are an important contaminant to test for, regardless of your water supply. Berkey water filters do not reduce nitrates. While commonly associated with agriculture, nitrates can make their way into any water supply and have been linked with health issues, particularly for infants.
If nitrates are present in your water supply, a Berkey might not be the right fit for you.
Should I Test My Berkey for PFAS?
Berkey claims to remove 99.9% of nine types of PFAS (including PFOS and PFOA). While activated carbon treatment is currently the most studied effective removal treatment for PFAS you may want to know more about your specific PFAS levels. Test specifically for PFAS.
Should I Test My Berkey for Pesticides, VOCs, or Other Industrial Contaminants?
Berkeys claim to remove 99.9% of VOCs, pesticides and herbicides—including glyphosate, a widely used herbicide in industrial agriculture operations. Pesticides and herbicides are largely a concern for well owners and depend on whether or not you live near large agricultural operations.
- VOCs (or volatile organic compounds) include a wide range of contaminants. Disinfection byproducts (DPBs) are a type of VOC prevalent in municipal water supplies and a concern for city or tap water users. Other VOCs (like petro-chemicals and industrial solvents) are a concern if you live near oil and gas and other industrial operations. Test for VOCs.
Remember: Be sure to confirm your test kit includes the contaminants you are looking to test for.
How to Performance Test Your Berkey
Performance testing your Berkey is easy—two tests in two steps!
- Choosing the right test for your water. Understanding your water source is key as it has a direct impact on your unique contaminant profile.
- If you get your water from a city/public utility, we highly recommend the Advanced City Water Test because it includes disinfection byproducts (DBPs) in addition to heavy metals (e.g. lead)—the two most prevalent contaminants in municipal water systems.
- If you get your water from a private well, we recommend the Essential Well Water Test because it provides you with a baseline evaluation of well water quality, including bacteria and nitrates. (Remember, wells should be tested annually.)
- If you haven’t tested your well in a long while (or ever) OR want to stress-test your Berkey against a comprehensive list of contaminants, we recommend the Extended Well Water Test. (Well water varies greatly. Don’t hesitate to talk to our team if you’re unsure which test is right for your location.)
- If you use your Berkey to purify water harvested from rainfall or a spring, we recommend the Essential Rainwater Test or the Advanced Spring Water Test.
182 Analytes Tested
Comprehensive testing for popular well water issues, plus additional risk factors including radioactive particles, radon, tannins, bacteria, plasticizers and pesticides.
- Collecting your samples. Your tests will come with detailed instructions for collecting your sample, and how to ship accordingly. Take a look at our optimal performance testing tips below.
Tips for Optimal Performance Testing
- We recommend testing shortly after you’ve acquired your Berkey, or right after filter replacement.
- Remember to follow all of Berkey’s preparatory instructions for use—like soaking and initial flushing—before conducting your test.
- Just before testing, empty your Berkey of any remaining water in the system.
- For highest accuracy, we recommend collecting a large amount of water from the source you intend to test (e.g. using a bucket, sanitized and then rinsed with the same water you intend to test). Then, taking extra care to avoid contaminating any water with your hands, it’s as easy as 1-2-3.
- Take one test sample from the unfiltered, collected water right away.
- Fill your Berkey with the unfiltered, collected water and let it work its way through filtration.
- Collect your second, filtered sample from your Berkey’s spigot.
A Couple of Performance Tests Done Right
Because Berkey water systems are not NSF/ANSI certified, we’d recommend keeping tabs on your filter’s performance at regular intervals to compare both flow rate and filter effectiveness until you feel confident in your Berkey’s performance.
You can expect a filter’s performance to degrade over time but, without certifications, you can’t reliably know exactly when or how drastically. We recommend testing at least annually, more frequently if your usage is high or your water quality is questionable.
Why Trust Tap Score?
We know how confusing it can be to find advice on water quality and treatment you can trust. That’s part of the reason we made Tap Score—to help improve the way you test and treat your drinking water.
- No affiliate links: Unlike most sites revolving around water quality, we do not take a cut from sales on filtration systems.
- Unbiased advice: Our blog is independently researched by our team of water scientists and designed to provide clarity on water quality, not to sell treatment products.
- Independent laboratory testing: Tap Score test results come from SimpleLab's third-party network of certified laboratories; in other words, accredited labs provide the data without conflicts of interest.
- Continuously updated: Science never rests. That’s why our content always reflects the latest developments in scientific research and regulatory standards.
- Always available: Our customer service team is the best in the industry and available anytime via chat to answer all your water quality questions.
Shop our most
I Have City Water
I Have Well Water